Malta Bill 55 stays in force after the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) ruled on 19 November that an Austrian court’s questions on the law, in Case C-683/24 Spielerschutz Sigma, were inadmissible, leaving its compatibility with EU law undecided.
Bill 55, passed in June 2023, added Article 56A to the Maltese Gaming Act. The provision tells Maltese courts, on public policy grounds, to refuse recognition and enforcement of foreign judgments against operators holding a Maltese licence, and bars such actions from being brought in Malta.
The Spielerschutz Sigma case
Spielerschutz Sigma Prozessfinanzierungs GmbH, an Austrian litigation funder, finances claims by players in Austria against Malta-licensed operators that offered online gambling there without an Austrian licence. Austrian courts have ordered those operators to repay players’ losses in numerous judgments, which the company is seeking to enforce in Malta, according to the CJEU’s press release on the judgment.
The company asked a legal adviser to assess the risk Bill 55 posed to its business. The adviser concluded that the amendment was manifestly contrary to EU law and would not be applied in Maltese enforcement proceedings. A Maltese court later rejected Spielerschutz Sigma’s request to enforce an Austrian judgment on the basis of Article 56A.
Spielerschutz Sigma then sued the adviser before the Commercial Court, Vienna, seeking a refund of its fees and damages for the proceedings it funded between the date of the opinion and the date it learned of the Maltese refusal. The Vienna court referred several questions on Article 56A to the CJEU.
Why the CJEU did not rule on Malta Bill 55
The CJEU held that a national court may only refer questions whose answer it needs to decide the dispute before it. Whether the adviser was negligent depends on Austrian law, and on whether the opinion was reasonably defensible on the law and information available when it was written, the court said.
The CJEU found that the parties’ obligations under the consultation contract do not depend on whether the Maltese law complies with EU law. The questions therefore sought an advisory opinion on general or hypothetical points, which the court does not give.
The Advocate General’s view
The judgment follows the line taken by Advocate General Nicholas Emiliou in his opinion of 23 April 2026, which also proposed declaring the reference inadmissible. In the alternative, Emiliou said Article 56A was manifestly incompatible with the recognition and enforcement rules of the Brussels I bis Regulation, according to the CJEU’s press release on the opinion.
Emiliou said Malta could not rely on the public policy clause to refuse judgments it considered a misapplication of EU law, and that a Maltese licence is generally valid only in Malta. The CJEU confirmed in April that member states may prohibit online gambling services authorised in another member state, a ruling covered in local gambling laws override MGA licences.
Next steps
The Commercial Court, Vienna will now decide Spielerschutz Sigma’s damages claim against its adviser under Austrian law. Article 56A remains on the statute book, and the question of its compatibility with EU law, first raised in the EU legal challenge to Bill 55, stays open for other proceedings involving MGA-licensed operators.
Source: Court of Justice of the European Union










