The chair of the Dutch gambling regulator says national enforcement cannot reach the operators taking half of the money Dutch players gamble, and he wants the response moved to European level.
Michel Groothuizen, chair of the Kansspelautoriteit, made the argument in a blog published on 11 September, written after the Tweede Kamer held its annual commissiedebat on gambling. The debate ran through the agenda he expected, and he came away from it with one thing he wanted added.
“I felt that almost all spokespersons lacked focus on one important point: our international clout.”
Half of every euro
The numbers Groothuizen used are the KSA’s own. Of every euro Dutch people gamble, half goes to the illegal market. The Dutch state loses more than €500m a year in tax that unlicensed operators never pay. Globally, he put the illegal gambling market above the GDP of every country except the United States and China.
His complaint is about scale. The KSA works inside one jurisdiction. The operators it chases work across all of them, with payment flows, corporate structures and social media advertising spread over several countries at once.
“In my view, it is naive to cling to the idea that a well-regulated legal national market and a national regulator are sufficient to tackle this problem.”
He put the mismatch in policing terms.
“We are fighting a global network of ruthless criminal organisations with dedicated community police officers, whereas we should actually be deploying an international investigative service.”
Fines that land and then sit there
The KSA has not been quiet on enforcement. In March it issued a penalty of €24.8m against Novatech, the largest in the regulator’s history, alongside a second penalty for unlicensed supply announced the same day. Collection is where it stops. Groothuizen’s assessment of what follows a penalty decision is “not much payment of fines.”
“We impose fines running into the tens of millions, but which are, relatively speaking, only a fraction of what they would have had to pay in taxes on their profits if they had been legal.”
That arithmetic is the core of his case. A fine an operator can absorb, and may never pay, does not change the economics of staying offshore. He tied the enforcement gap directly to where the companies sit.
“Their entire habitat is international, from financial flows to advertisements on social media. Real impact requires clout at the European level.”
What the Kamer debated
The commissiedebat ran through a full domestic agenda: stronger player protection, cutting the number of licence holders, widening and accelerating advertising restrictions, raising the minimum age to 21, a central login portal for licensed operators, blocking instruments for illegal sites, and tackling false identities used to get around controls. The government is separately pursuing a blanket ban on gambling advertising.
Groothuizen did not argue against any of it. His point was what the attention ratio does downstream. A “lack of attention” from parliament on European rules, he said, means “the department will also work on European rules only sporadically.”
He also noted that illegal sites actively court the players Dutch policy is built to protect, including people registered in Cruks, the national self-exclusion register. Those players have closed the legal door and find the illegal one open.
The European gap
There is no European enforcement body for gambling. Cooperation between EU regulators runs largely through the Gaming Regulators European Forum, which shares information and coordinates positions without investigative powers of its own. Gambling remains a national competence, and successive attempts to move it up a level have run into member states that want to keep it.
Pieces of a European conversation are appearing from other directions. Polish prime minister Donald Tusk has floated an EU-level tax on gambling and crypto as a bloc revenue source, a proposal that assumes European competence over the sector. National regulators, meanwhile, keep hitting the limits Groothuizen describes. In Sweden, the consumer ombudsman has taken a lottery operator to court over Instagram advertising, a national action against content served by an international platform.
What happens next
Groothuizen’s blog is a regulator’s chair saying publicly that the tools he has been given do not match the problem he has been asked to solve, in the week his political overseers spent their annual gambling debate on domestic measures. It carries no draft text and no route through Brussels.
The Dutch advertising ban, the age-21 proposal and the central login portal will move on their own timetable in The Hague. Whether international enforcement gets added to that list depends on whether the Ministry of Justice and Security picks it up, and Groothuizen has said what he thinks the odds of that are. The next channelisation figures will show what the domestic measures did to the other half of the euro.
Source: Kansspelautoriteit










